Was Persona 5 Worth the Wait?
Persona 5 is a game that I have been looking forward to for the better part of a decade. Persona is a series that I hold dear, and while I'm not so fond of the initial entry (which came to the US under the title Revelations: Persona), the rest of the series has been so stellar that I think I can safely say that Persona is my favorite RPG series.
While Persona was a fantastic JRPG in its own right, Persona 3 revolutionized the genre with an emphasis on time management and maintaining relationships with friends in order to strengthen innate abilities. It was an ambitious concept that was executed impressively, but the game had sizable flaws, such as bland randomized dungeons and inconsistent pacing. Persona 3 was easily able to overcome its flaws with a combination of addictive gameplay and jaw-dropping style, and it earned itself a loyal audience while establishing a new direction for the series.
Persona 4 was a near-perfect follow-up to Persona 3, keeping its predecessor's vibrant, hyper-modern style while addressing each and every one of its flaws. Dungeons remain randomized, but each has a distinct visual style that ties into the story. Pacing is also no longer an issue, with an overarching story that is made apparent from the get-go, and a tight-knit case of likable characters that you really want to get to know better. The game steadily built a rabid following and was eventually successful enough to spawn a handful of spin-offs, including a fighting game and even a dancing-themed rhythm game.
Anticipation was high for Persona 5, and it certainly took its time to hit shelves. After a tumultuous development period spanning eight whole years and an entire console generation (the longest console generation, naturally), the mammoth sequel finally found its way to the PlayStation 4 and into the hands of fans with very high expectations. After spending the last month playing through the game, I'm happy to say that it's a sequel worthy of its pedigree, and easily one of the best games in a year full of amazing games.
The developers of Persona 5 wisely chose to stick with the same winning formula that made the previous two games so successful, focusing their efforts on polishing the game's presentation to a blinding sheen. Everything in Persona 5, from the general user interface to screen transitions, oozes style and personality, and there is never a dull moment visually. The presentation in Persona 5, bolstered by vibrant art by character designer Shigenori Soejima and a brilliant, jazz-infused soundtrack by series veteran Shoji Meguro, is one for the ages, and makes most other games feel lifeless in comparison.
Gameplay has not changed much since Persona 4, with the same addictive cycle of school and free social time leading up to lengthy dungeon dives. Persona 5's battle mechanics also adhere to those of Persona 3 and 4, for the most part. Combat is snappy and has a nice flow to it, with helpful button shortcuts that let you exploit an enemy's weakness in the blink of an eye. Downing an entire group of enemies and defeating them with a group attack rewards you with a nice bit of character-centric art, which, along with the awesome victory screen, is a nice way to keep combat from feeling tiresome.
In an unexpected nod to the mainline Shin Megami Tensei games and the original Persona, you recruit Personas by negotiating with enemies. Successful negotiation depends on answering demons in a manner that complements their personality type, but figuring out the correct response can feel like an exercise in frustration. Fortunately, you can still create Personas through fusion, and don't have to renegotiate with any demon who you have recruited in the past.
The dungeons (referred to in the game as "palaces") are vastly improved from Persona 4, and are no longer randomized. Each has a specific theme, and their design makes them feel like the manifestation of their ruler's twisted desires that they should be. My biggest complaint about the palaces in Persona 5 is that you are often forced to leave them at least once before reaching the goal due to story-related reasons. With limited time to socialize with friends, it's always preferable to get through a palace in as few days as possible.
Persona 5 is so dedicated to ironing out the few flaws that impacted prior games that it can be difficult to find anything significant to criticize. My biggest complaint is that the game feels like it could have been shorter without sacrificing quality. It never feels like it's paced poorly, but by the time I crossed the 120-hour mark, I was felt ready to see the story's resolution and move on to something else, because lord knows there are plenty of other 2017 games worthy of my time as well.
Judged objectively, Persona 5 is the best game in the series. It has a solid narrative with consistent and timely themes and an incredibly addictive gameplay loop complemented by an inspired presentation. The characters are mostly very likable, with one or two exceptions (chill out, Ryuji!), and I look forward to spending more time with them in the umpteen spin-offs that will inevitably be released over the next decade. I likely won't be replaying Persona 5 anytime soon (if ever) due to its insane length, but I genuinely enjoyed every one of the roughly 140 hours spent with it.
For Persona fans, a purchase is a no-brainer, but Persona 5 is also an excellent starting point for those unfamiliar with the series. It's an immense game that somehow lives up to the titanic hype that has steadily built over the last decade, and it will undoubtedly influence console RPGs for years to come.
Gameplay has not changed much since Persona 4, with the same addictive cycle of school and free social time leading up to lengthy dungeon dives. Persona 5's battle mechanics also adhere to those of Persona 3 and 4, for the most part. Combat is snappy and has a nice flow to it, with helpful button shortcuts that let you exploit an enemy's weakness in the blink of an eye. Downing an entire group of enemies and defeating them with a group attack rewards you with a nice bit of character-centric art, which, along with the awesome victory screen, is a nice way to keep combat from feeling tiresome.
In an unexpected nod to the mainline Shin Megami Tensei games and the original Persona, you recruit Personas by negotiating with enemies. Successful negotiation depends on answering demons in a manner that complements their personality type, but figuring out the correct response can feel like an exercise in frustration. Fortunately, you can still create Personas through fusion, and don't have to renegotiate with any demon who you have recruited in the past.
The dungeons (referred to in the game as "palaces") are vastly improved from Persona 4, and are no longer randomized. Each has a specific theme, and their design makes them feel like the manifestation of their ruler's twisted desires that they should be. My biggest complaint about the palaces in Persona 5 is that you are often forced to leave them at least once before reaching the goal due to story-related reasons. With limited time to socialize with friends, it's always preferable to get through a palace in as few days as possible.
Persona 5 is so dedicated to ironing out the few flaws that impacted prior games that it can be difficult to find anything significant to criticize. My biggest complaint is that the game feels like it could have been shorter without sacrificing quality. It never feels like it's paced poorly, but by the time I crossed the 120-hour mark, I was felt ready to see the story's resolution and move on to something else, because lord knows there are plenty of other 2017 games worthy of my time as well.
Judged objectively, Persona 5 is the best game in the series. It has a solid narrative with consistent and timely themes and an incredibly addictive gameplay loop complemented by an inspired presentation. The characters are mostly very likable, with one or two exceptions (chill out, Ryuji!), and I look forward to spending more time with them in the umpteen spin-offs that will inevitably be released over the next decade. I likely won't be replaying Persona 5 anytime soon (if ever) due to its insane length, but I genuinely enjoyed every one of the roughly 140 hours spent with it.
For Persona fans, a purchase is a no-brainer, but Persona 5 is also an excellent starting point for those unfamiliar with the series. It's an immense game that somehow lives up to the titanic hype that has steadily built over the last decade, and it will undoubtedly influence console RPGs for years to come.
No comments:
Post a Comment